News

Home » News » Another convict in Nirbhaya Gangrape case files curative petition in SC


Mukesh, another death row convict in the Nirbhaya gangrape case has filed a Curative petition in the Supreme Court to commute his death penalty to life imprisonment.

The petition filed by Advocate Vrinda Grover, appearing for Mukesh stated that subsequent to the impugned judgment, there has been a sea change in the jurisprudence of death sentencing in India. The petition referred to the judgment of Navneet Kaur vs. State (2014) where the Supreme Court overturned the death sentence in curative proceedings implying to the subsequent change in the law.

Citing the doctrine of ‘residual doubt,’ the petition claimed that “The Petitioner has a sufficient cause for there being a residual doubt regarding his role in the offense. Only the DNA of the other accused Ram Singh (who reportedly committed suicide in jail) was recovered from the private parts of the deceased (Nirbhaya). Further, the disclosure statement of the main accused ‘Ram Singh’ states that while all the accused participated in the crime, it was Ram Singh’s acts alone that caused the grievous injuries to the victim.”

The petition further stated that imposing the death sentence on the petitioner would be a grave violation of Article 14 as well as Article 21 of the Indian Constitution.

Earlier on 9 January, the other convict Vinay Sharma filed a curative petition in the Supreme Court claiming that he was only 19-years-old while he committed the crime and stated that his family will be destroyed if he is executed.

Related News


Jharkhand High Court Rejected Lalu Prasad’s Bail Plea

Jharkhand High Court Rejected Lalu Prasad’s Bail Plea

The Rashtriya Janata Dal chief, Lalu Prasad Yadav, was rejected bail on 6 December 2019, by the Jharkhand High Court concerning to multi-crore fodder scam case. The case pertains to the fraudulent withdrawal of Rs 3.5 crore from the Dumka treasury by Animal Husbandry Department officials in the 1990s when Lalu was the undivided state’s, […]

Speedy Disposal In The Cases Of Brutality Against Women – CM Jagan Mohan Reddy

Speedy Disposal In The Cases Of Brutality Against Women – CM Jagan Mohan Reddy

On 11 December, the Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister, Jagan Mohan Reddy authorized two draft bills to dispose of the cases of atrocities against women, within 21 days. The first bill is an amendment to the AP Criminal Law and named as the ‘AP Disha Act’ dedicatory to the gang-rape and murder of Hyderabad veterinary doctor. […]

Direction to NHRC to probe police action at Aligarh Muslim University – Allahabad HC

Direction to NHRC to probe police action at Aligarh Muslim University – Allahabad HC

The Allahabad High Court through its judgment dated 7 January directed the National Human Rights Commission to investigate the alleged police violence in AMU, during the anti-Citizenship Amendment Act protests. The two-judge bench headed by Chief Justice Govind Mathur, while hearing a PIL filed by one Mohammad Aman Khan seeking a judicial inquiry by a […]

Unnao Rape Case Update- Former BJP MLA, Kuldeep Sengar Guilty of Rape

Unnao Rape Case Update- Former BJP MLA, Kuldeep Sengar Guilty of Rape

The Delhi Court on 16 December, held the expelled BJP MLA- Kuldeep Singh Sengar, guilty of kidnap and rape of a minor girl in Unnao, Uttar Pradesh. The quantum of sentencing is scheduled in the hearing on 19 December. The bench headed by Judge Dharmesh Sharma asserted the concern on part of CBI, for delayed […]


Head Office
#588, Sector 6
Panchkula, Haryana, 134109

Chandigarh
#624 Sector 16-D
Chandigarh, 160015

Panchkula
#52, Swastik Vihar-II MDC
Sector 5, Panchkula, 134114

Faridabad
360, Sector 19 ,
Faridabad Haryana 121007

Noida
501, KT – 4, Jaypee’s Wish Town,
Sector 128, Noida, NCR 201304

Dehradun
A-1-4 Pinnacle Residency,
Rajpur Road, Dehradun

Lucknow
565KA/94, Amrudhi Bagh, Singar Nagar,
Alambagh, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh 226005

Ludhiana
#33, Sector 2, Guru Gian Vihar,
Jawaddi Taksal, Ludhiana, Punjab 141002